State Affordable Health Plans should be preserved

Association of Washington BusinessDecember 4, 2013 

Washington State Insurance Commissioner Mike Kreidler made national news when he quickly rejected President Obama’s call for insurers to extend individual health insurance policies that were canceled because of the Affordable Care Act, also referred to as Obamacare.

While 5 million insurance policies have been canceled to date, the Obama administration estimated that as many as 18 million of those policies will be canceled because of the ACA. In Washington state, some 290,000 people already have received cancellation notices.

While Kreidler and Obamacare supporters say the coverage was substandard anyway, those policies were all accepted by the Office of the Insurance Commissioner.

In the wake of his announcement, Kreidler sought to reassure consumers, saying the canceled individual policies are just a small part of the market and suggesting most people aren’t affected because they’re insured through their employers.

Many others have an opposite view.

In fact, in 2010, the Obama administration estimated half of all employer-based policies would be illegal under the ACA. And just a few weeks ago, the Justice Department reiterated in federal court documents that a majority of employer-based health plans are expected to be canceled because of the ACA.

How many people could that affect? The Congressional Budget Office estimates 156 million Americans — more than half the population — are covered by employer-sponsored insurance.

In a recent interview with The Washington Post, Kreidler said he rejected the president’s call to extend canceled policies because it could cause confusion and destabilize the state insurance market.

But months ago, the commissioner stopped insurers in our state from renewing their employer-based policies early — before they expired — even though nothing in state or federal law prohibits it.

The commissioner also has repeatedly moved against a popular category of comprehensive and affordable employer-based health plans enjoyed by nearly 500,000 people in Washington who depend on their small-business jobs for health insurance. They’re called Association Health Plans, or AHPs.

AHPs were approved under Gov. Mike Lowry in 1995 as a way to help small employers provide high-quality, more affordable health coverage for their workers. A strong majority of Democrat and Republican lawmakers voted for the bill.

In 2007, Kreidler tried to change the rules on AHPs, even though he had no authority under state law to do so. It would have restricted the ability of small employers to purchase coverage through AHPs, but he didn’t ask the Legislature for the authority to make those changes.

A Spokane court found that, when he acting unilaterally, Kreidler had disregarded the separation-of-powers doctrine and violated both state law and the state constitution.

The court ruling allowed small employers to continue to purchase more affordable, comprehensive coverage for their workers and families.

As a result, Washington’s small employers have had access to some of the best coverage and rates in the nation.

Kreidler is again trying to strip small employers of their access to AHPs, this time suggesting they don’t comply with Obamacare. But state law makes it clear AHPs can continue, even under federal programs like Obamacare.

And, of course, Obama made it clear that states could allow you to keep your plan, if you like it.

Needless to say, this is causing uncertainty and confusion in Washington’s private health insurance market — the very thing Kreidler says he wants to avoid.

Kreidler says he’s doing everything he can to implement the federal Affordable Care Act. But, as Washington’s insurance commissioner, his first duty is to comply with state law, and that means defending and preserving AHPs for the half-million people who depend on them.

Don Brunell is the president of the Association of Washington Business, which serves as both the state’s chamber of commerce and the manufacturing and technology association. For more information, visit

The Peninsula Gateway is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service